Back to list
lottery methodscomparisonroulettepaper lottery

Lottery Methods Compared: Roulette, Paper Draws, Ghost Leg

· · Amida-san

Prize drawings, role assignments, and team splits each suit a different lottery method. This article compares six common methods and explains how to choose.

Comparing a roulette wheel, a lottery box, and an amidakuji lined up on a shelf

Six Lottery Methods

Paper Draw

All you need is paper and a pen, and everyone understands it. But everyone must be in the same room, and it is hard to verify the slips beforehand. Duplicates and missing numbers happen easily, so it suits in-person groups of about 10 or fewer.

Lottery Machine (Garapon)

The balls are visible, so the process is easy to follow, and turning the handle adds excitement. You need to rent or buy the machine and find space for it, and it cannot be used online. It fits in-person events where presentation matters, such as festivals and large parties.

Roulette (Web or App)

Many free tools exist and they work on smartphones. Because only the organizer operates it, people may wonder whether it is really random. It suits small, casual groups that already trust each other.

Spreadsheet Random Numbers

Functions such as RAND generate random numbers. There is no extra cost, and it is quick when the list is already in a spreadsheet. It requires formula knowledge, and people may suspect the formula was changed. It suits internal administrative drawings.

Rock-Paper-Scissors

No preparation, and everyone sees the process. With more people, ties drag on, so it suits quick decisions among 2 to 5 people.

Online Ghost Leg (Amidakuji)

Participants draw their own horizontal rungs, and the result is decided by tracing the lines. Each person always gets exactly one distinct result, and because everyone takes part in building the diagram, no single person can easily steer the outcome. With Amida-san, you share one URL and up to 299 people can join an event. It needs an internet connection, and first-time users need a short explanation. It fits online events and company parties with remote participants where buy-in matters.

Six people join a holiday party prize draw, and every ball traces the lines to decide the first, second, and third prize winners

Comparison Table

Item Paper Draw Garapon Roulette Spreadsheet Rock-Paper-Scissors Ghost Leg
Transparency △ ○ △ △ ◎ ◎
Setup Time 5-15 min 30-60 min 1-5 min 5-10 min 0 min 1-5 min
Suitable Size Up to ~10 Up to ~100 No limit No limit Up to ~5 Up to 299
Online × × ○ ○ △ ◎
Cost Free Paid Free Free Free Free
Participants Involved △ △ × × ◎ ◎

What Makes a Lottery Fair

A fair lottery gives every outcome the same probability, cannot be predicted in advance, and never assigns the same result twice. Participants also need to be convinced it was not manipulated.

With roulette or a spreadsheet, the random numbers may be fine, but participants cannot see the process. Rock-paper-scissors is visible, but ties and mind games come into play. Ghost leg cannot produce duplicate results, and since everyone draws rungs, the process is shared. See Proving Ghost Leg Fairness with Math for details.

Choosing by Scenario

  • Corporate prize drawings (50-200 people): online ghost leg if remote staff join; a garapon if fully in person and budget allows
  • Picking a party organizer (5-15 people): rock-paper-scissors for speed, ghost leg to avoid complaints later
  • Classroom role assignment (20-40 students): ghost leg, because the process is visible. See the school lottery guide
  • Online seminar giveaways: a method people can join by URL. Amida-san supports up to 299 per event
  • Large events with 500+ visitors: a garapon for stage presentation, or a dedicated lottery system for efficiency

For prize drawings, also check the legal considerations in advance.

Summary

Choose online ghost leg for fairness and transparency, rock-paper-scissors for quick decisions in small groups, a garapon for in-person presentation, and roulette or a spreadsheet for convenience. Decide based on group size, location, and what matters most.


Try Amida-san Now!

Experience fair and transparent drawing with our simple and easy-to-use online ladder lottery tool.

Try it Now