Back to list
SchoolEducationRole AssignmentGroup Division

Fair Ways to Decide Classroom Roles, Groups, and Turn Order

· · Amida-san

The moment a teacher says "Let's decide classroom jobs," the room fills with "Me!" and "No way!" Schools decide something nearly every day: jobs, groups, presentation order. When the method is unclear, resentment lingers; when it is transparent, students accept the result more easily even if it is not what they wanted. This article covers fair methods for each situation.

An amidakuji drawn in chalk on a classroom blackboard, with children in front of it

Classroom Jobs and Duties

Early elementary

Some children cannot read well yet, so explain each job with pictures or photos and ask for three choices. Use Amida-san only for jobs with overlapping requests, and show the lines being traced on a projector so children can see it is fair. For children who did not get their first choice, point out what is good about their job and give them priority next time.

Upper elementary

Popular jobs attract many requests, and friends want to stay together. Combine these approaches:

  • Discuss first, and use an amidakuji (ghost leg lottery) only for what cannot be agreed
  • Rate jobs by workload, and give priority to students who had a heavy job last time
  • Rotate jobs each term, with the rotation order decided by lottery, so everyone tries every job

Middle and high school

Class representatives and student council roles should be filled by volunteers and elections, with nominations or a lottery only when no one runs. For classroom jobs, collect preferences with a form and use an online lottery for the parts that need adjusting. Students can join from their own school devices.

Forming Groups

Random groups

Useful for new classes or when groups have become fixed. With small numbers, playing card suits work. With Amida-san, set group names as allocations, share the URL at the start of class, and have students join from their devices. Up to 299 people can join one lottery, so it also works for a whole grade.

Joining "Team split" on a phone by entering a name and drawing a horizontal line

Groups that reflect preferences

For field trip groups or school festival projects, ask students to list three to five people they want to work with, and build groups around matching requests. Using a lottery only for the remaining adjustments avoids the impression that the teacher arranged things.

Deciding Order

  • Presentation order. Draw it randomly, or put last time's later presenters first. Decide in advance so students have time to prepare
  • Lab or practical order. Draw the order for all groups, post it, and reverse it next time
  • Lunch and cleaning duties. Decide all weeks at the start of term, and set a rule for absences (for example, "the next person covers")

Running It in Class

  1. Create an amidakuji on Amida-san with job or group names as allocations, and show the QR code on screen
  2. Explain that "everyone draws a line together, so nobody knows the result in advance"
  3. Each student enters a name and draws a line. If devices are short, the teacher enters for them
  4. Start once everyone has joined, and check the result together on screen
  5. Copy the result into the class log

Depending on class size, about 15 minutes from explanation to record is typical.

Six people in a team split, with each ball following the lines to the red team or the blue team

Explaining to Parents

In the class newsletter, explain that everyone takes part, that the teacher cannot choose the result, and why you use this method. Adding that you help students understand the process was fair, even when they are disappointed, makes it easier for parents to accept.

Frequently Asked Questions

How should I handle students unhappy with the result?

Explain that the process was fair and point out what is good about their role. A promise of priority next time also helps.

What if someone is absent?

Set a substitution rule in advance. Redrawing among those present or having the next person cover are simple options.

Summary

At school, draw lots only for what discussion and preferences can't settle, and let students see how the decision is made; they accept the result more easily, even when it isn't what they wanted. Set rules for absences and priority next time in advance, and explain the method to parents in the class newsletter.

Related Articles


Try Amida-san Now!

Experience fair and transparent drawing with our simple and easy-to-use online ladder lottery tool.

Try it Now