Back to list
Online ClassesWebinarRandom SelectionEducationUniversityE-LearningRemote Education

Random Student Selection in Online Classes: Methods Compared

· · Amida-san

In online classes, raised hands and eye contact don't work, so a few students do all the talking while most just watch. This article covers ways to call on students at random and form groups online, and how to use them in class.

A teacher points at the highlighted student among the remote students shown on a classroom screen

Common Problems in Online Classes

  • The same students always speak. With many cameras off, it is hard to notice who has not spoken
  • Raised hands get missed. In large lectures, tracking raised hands in the participant list while teaching is difficult
  • Groups become fixed. Setting up breakout rooms takes effort, so groups tend to stay the same

Comparing Random Selection Methods

Method Pros Cons
Instructor picks from the participant list No setup Subjective, and no record
Spreadsheet random numbers (=RAND()) Free and easy Results change on recalculation, and students cannot see the process
Spinner wheel sites Fun to watch Only the instructor operates it, and entering many names takes time
Polling tools Good for gathering opinions Voting, not random selection
Amida-san Students draw their own lines and can check the result via URL The amidakuji (ghost leg lottery) needs a short explanation at first

Amida-san requires no registration; students join from a URL or QR code. One lottery holds up to 299 participants, so split larger lectures into separate draws.

Joining "Presentation order" on a phone by entering a name and drawing a horizontal line

Steps for a Large Lecture

An example of calling on three students at random each week in a lecture of about 100:

  1. The week before, announce that random calling will start, so students can prepare
  2. At the start of class, create an amidakuji with three "Selected" allocations and everyone else in "Others Allocation," and post the URL in chat
  3. Students enter their names and draw lines by a deadline (about five minutes). The instructor adds anyone who could not join
  4. Start the draw, have the three selected students speak, and build the discussion from there
  5. Copy the result into your class records or LMS

Six people in a presentation order draw, with each ball following the lines to a slot from 1st to 6th

Keep a record of who has been selected over the term, and ask those already called to sit out later draws, so everyone gets at least one turn. Not knowing when you will be called also encourages preparation.

Early on, students may worry about being called when unprepared. Give advance notice and say "It's fine if you can't answer, we'll think it through together" to keep the atmosphere safe.

Other Uses

  • Seminar presentation order. Deciding all sessions at the start of term helps students plan
  • Group work. Use group names as allocations and reshuffle weekly so students work with different people
  • Webinar Q&A. When many want to ask questions, draw who gets called and give priority next time to those not chosen
  • Training role-plays. Draw roles such as customer, salesperson, and observer each time
  • Flipped classroom presenters. Announcing that presenters will be drawn on the day gets everyone to prepare

What to Look for in a Tool

  • Students can take part themselves. Results are easier to accept than with a tool only the instructor operates
  • It handles your class size
  • No registration. You avoid collecting email addresses and reduce friction
  • Results can be checked later. Amida-san results of a free event stay viewable for 180 days after creation, so copy long-term records into your LMS
  • Free or low cost

Frequently Asked Questions

What if a selected student has their camera off?

Focus on what they say rather than whether their camera is on. A light rule such as "camera on only while speaking" is one option.

Does it integrate with an LMS?

There is no automatic integration. Paste the result URL or details into your LMS forum or announcements.

What if webinar participants want to stay anonymous?

Have them join with numbers or nicknames instead of real names. Display names are visible to anyone with the URL.

Summary

To stop a few students from doing all the talking, call on students at random with a method they join themselves, and track who has been selected so everyone gets a turn. Start by announcing random calling the week before, and tell students it's fine if they can't answer.

Related Articles


Try Amida-san Now!

Experience fair and transparent drawing with our simple and easy-to-use online ladder lottery tool.

Try it Now